How e.l.f. Cosmetics Built a $1B Empire Selling $1 Lipstick

Most beauty brands competed for the luxury market. e.l.f. Cosmetics created their own category. By redefining what "affordable" could mean and proving prestige quality didn't require premium prices, they sparked a movement that challenged industry fundamentals and captured an entire generation.

Here’s what you’ll learn: 

For decades, the beauty industry operated on a simple formula: premium quality meant premium prices. Legacy brands built their empires on $30-$50 lipsticks and foundations, and 8-figure celebrity endorsements. Young consumers craved the glamorous looks they saw across television and social media, but often couldn’t afford such a lofty tag for just a single product, leaving the average Gen Z and Millennial consumer priced out of the luxury. With those legacy brands so focused on affluent shoppers, a massive market gap continued to grow. And when inflation started to squeeze wallets, even some of those anchor customers began hunting for value alternatives. The industry was ready for a makeover.

In 2004, e.l.f. Cosmetics came on the scene with a bold and unheard of proposition, sell prestige-inspired products, direct to consumer, for under $5. Industry veterans were skeptical, but the founders saw what legacy brands missed, consumer habits were changing. 

The market responded immediately. In their first year e.l.f. raked in $1.5M averaging thousands of orders daily. Here was a brand offering prestige-style products without the luxury markup. Glamour had become accessible on a broke college student’s budget. 

But could they scale while maintaining quality? Legacy brands avoided this end of the market for a reason, the math didn’t work.

We’ve built a stable of partnerships to help you level up, including a free year from Atlassian, Auth0, Intercom, Serverspace, GitHub, and more.

But it doesn’t stop there. How about $50K credits from Segment and Mixpanel? What about 6 free months of Gusto, Zendesk, or Notion?

Gain instant access to over $3,000,000 in value for one low price.

Upgrade without breaking the bank. (Some offers for new customers only.)

e.l.f. built a completely different business model than what the industry was used to, leveraging three pillars for disruption that the larger legacy brands couldn’t copy easily. Rather than chasing movie stars or supermodels, e.l.f. leaned into dupes and digital influencers.

Coming from fast fashion, they knew that speed wins. While traditional beauty brands ran focus groups and had to wait for celebrity approval, pushing production timelines for new products to 18-24 months, e.l.f. used social media to spot trends and push products in 26 weeks, producing affordable versions of prestige hits at unprecedented speed. When Dior launched a $40 viral lip oil, e.l.f. answered with an $8 version that fans said was just as good. When Charlotte Tilbury's $49 Hollywood Flawless Filter went viral, e.l.f. had their $14 version ready in months.

Within this crowdsourced product discovery also came another learning that would help move the market. Small and micro influencers with less than 100,000 followers were better for engagement and ROI than celebrities with millions of followers. What they might have lacked in “star power,” they made up for with trusting audiences and authenticity. Not to mention, they were much easier on the budget. Their early presence on TikTok in 2019 with the #EyesLipsFace challenge helped cement the brand with Gen Z, creating grassroots virality and complementing their style perfectly. 

None of this would have worked without the products to back it up. Instead of hiding from the luxury brand comparisons, they leaned in. Dupes went from embarrassing knockoffs to smart, budget-conscious shopping. e.l.f. successfully paired the hype with substance with its vegan, cruelty-free formulas, earning solid reviews, often beating originals in blind tests. Each pillar reinforced the others, creating a model and strategy that legacy brands found hard to replicate.

E.l.f.’s strategy has more than paid off. In 2024 the company hit $1 Billion in revenue with 77% growth, extending a streak of 26 straight quarters of sales growth and market share gains. They’re a mainstay in the beauty market, with 35% of U.S. teens naming them as their favorite brand and 9.5% U.S market share overall, beating out giants like CoverGirl and Revlon. What’s even more impressive is their gross margins of 71%, right on par with premium brands charging 3-4x as much, destroying the old ways of thinking that low prices mean low profits. 

Here are the takeaways you can apply

Speed and a first-mover advantage can beat perfect timing, but the product better hold up. e.l.f. was early to leverage TikTok and micro-influencers and pushed product cycles that made competitors reactive. They built operational advantages that helped them shape the market. 

Community beats celebrity because customers value authenticity. They built real relationships with real customers who in turn became some of their biggest genuine fans.

Own your narrative, and reframe the value conversation. e.l.f. didn’t let competitors define what affordable meant or let the market dictate their story. They positioned their offering as the valuable, intelligent choice, not a budget compromise or cheap alternative.

What if reading about money was the easiest part of making it? The Average Joe strips markets down to what matters and gives you financial insights you’ll actually use.

It’s read by more than 200K people — and roughly one in five are millionaires. 

Do they read it because they’re rich, or are they rich because they read it? 

We don’t run those studies.

👉 Get the free newsletter

$6 - the average price across e.l.f. Cosmetics’ 300+ SKUs 

$800M - The amount in cash and stock e.l.f. paid to acquire Hailey Bieber’s lifestyle beauty brand, Rhode.  

$296.8M - Adjusted EBITDA for FY Fiscal 2025 

2.5M - TikTok followers driving exception awareness among Gen Z and Millennials

#1 - e.l.f.’s brand position in the cosmetics category by unit share, where they are also number 2 by dollar share, making them the fastest growing company in the top 20.

Ready to tap into private credit? This mini-guide walks you through everything crucial: financial health checks, growth projections, must-have diligence docs, and the right questions to ask lenders. Get actionable tips to streamline your prep and stand out as a credible, attractive borrower. Want to see how it stacks up against a traditional bank loan? Start here.

It’s time to rewrite the rules of GTM. Don’t just watch change happen, lead the revolt. Happening Oct 20th–23rd, REVOLT! is a free virtual conference for the future of revenue creation, gathering the builders, breakers, and believers rewriting revenue playbooks. Expect high-signal sessions, hands-on hackathons, and behind-the-scenes roundtables with leaders from OpenAI, Beehiiv, GTM Fund, and more. Register for free to join the movement where sameness dies and fresh thinking thrives.

OpenAI and Oracle have reportedly signed a historic $300 billion cloud computing agreement, spanning nearly five years starting in 2027 and marking one of the largest deals of its kind, sending Oracle stock surging 40% with the announcement of the deal. OpenAI is also moving into the next phase of its Microsoft partnership with a non-binding MOU as they work to form the new deal.

If you aren’t leveraging AI in your business, you’re putting yourself at a disadvantage. Especially if you’re an SMB. Take a small step to give your marketing team some Aura.